Updated: 01/09/13
Current hours: Tuesday through Thursday 11 am to 9pm, Friday 11am until 10 pm. Saturday 3pm to 10pm, and Sunday 3pm to 9pm. Check out our specials page for daily updates!
We are now delivering Tuesday through Sunday, Starting at 4:30. We will start delivering at lunch if there is a demand for it.
Check us out on facebook for the most current information and specials. http://www.facebook.com/tomatopies or on twitter: @tomatopies
*Most menu items can be made Gluten Free. Just ask!
Authentic Hand-Crafted Tomato Pies
503 w main st. Sun prairie, wi. 608.318.1761
Antipasto
House-made bread with rosemary infused olive oil $3 House Salad- Mixed greens, wisconsin feta, cucumbers, heirloom tomatoes, shaved carrots, berries, tossed with our house made citrus dressing $7 (enough for two)
Garlic Bread- Madison Sourdough baguette, with real wisconsin butter, heirloom garlic. $4
Smoky cheese Bread – Madison sourdough baguette, garlic butter, Farmer John’s smoked gouda and colby caliente, with Jordandal Farms bacon. A local spin on a favorite. $7
Special Appetizer: House made hummus and pita chips, served with roasted organic Italian sweet red peppers and Brussels sprouts from Emerald Meadow Farm in Columbus, WI.
Wisconsin Meat and Cheese Board – Array of hand cured local meats by the Underground Food Collective in Madison. Options change often depending upon availability. Served with berries, Farmer John’s Blue cheese and an ever changing mix of other local items on a cutting board. Made from local heritage breed hogs. $13
Tomato Pies
One
The Tomato Pie — A trip to the past, when pizza wasn’t fast food. It’s all about the sauce. This recipe is nearly 100 years old. Made with the freshest tomatoes we can get, whole-milk (no part skim here) mozzarella, a little provolone, and fresh basil. 16” $14.79
Add your favorite Toppings. $2 * Premium Toppings *$3 **Super Premium $5
| Italian Sausage* | Pepperoni | Kalamata Olives * | Bacon |
| Tomatoes | Spinach | Black Olives | Feta |
| Goat Cheese * | Artichoke Hearts * | House Roasted Red Peppers * | Gorgonzola Cheese |
| Heirloom Garlic | Pesto | Prosciutto * | Fresh Mango * |
| Figs * | Red Onions | Anchovies* | Green Onions |
| Extra Cheese | Underground Meats Pepperoni ** | Banana Peppers | Caramelized Onions |
| WI Portobello Mushrooms | Fresh Basil* | Green peppers | Cilantro |
Two
Applewood – Smoky bacon, baby spinach, whole milk wisconsin mozzarella, romano, cherry and roma tomatoes. $18.99
Three
Underground Meats Peperone and Portobello — Farmhouse Peperone hand-crafted from locally raised heritage breed hogs by The Underground Food Collective, with Portobello Mushrooms from Helenville, WI, and Grande whole milk Mozzarella. A classic done right…and from local ingredients. $24
Four
Terrence’s Favorite— Fresh Italian Sausage, caramelized shallots, house roasted sweet red peppers, and goat cheese. $21
Five
Fresh Basil Pesto — Prosciutto, house made pesto,whole milk mozzarella,romano heirloom garlic and feta. $18.99
Six
Chicken pesto— Fresh basil pesto, caramelized onion, house roasted red peppers, heirloom garlic, whole milk mozzarella $22.50
Seven
Wine Poached Fig and Bacon – (Slice of Sun Prairie Pizza Contest Grand Champion)Cabernet poached mission figs, with gorgonzola cheese, whole milk mozzarella,balsamic/red wine reduction, and bacon. $22
Eight
The Fat Uncle Tony — The Tomato Pie, with smoky premium bacon, house made sausage, and pepperoni. $21
Nine
The Mediterranean Pie – Our signature crust, extra virgin olive oil, kalamata olives, feta cheese, whole milk mozzarella, roasted red peppers, heirloom garlic, artichokes, and Prosciutto. 22.50
Ten
El Valiente- Choice hanger steak, marinated with chipotle peppers, queso fresco, house chimichurri, garlic, goat cheese, roasted red peppers, Wisconsin portobello mushrooms, caramelized onion 22.50
Beverages
Coke, Diet Coke, Barq’s Root beer, Fanta Orange, Sprite, Sprite Zero. $1.25
Italian Sodas: San Pellegrino Limonata and Aranciata, $2.00
Gold Peak Iced Teas – Sweetened with lemon, and Unsweetened. $2.75
NessAlla Kombucha $4
Organic Chocolate Milk, $1.50
Madison’s Cargo Coffe
Dolce
Dessert selection changes often.
Beer:
Goose Island Bourbon County Bourbon Stout (limited time only!)
Goose Island Harvest Ale, Sophie, Matilda, Pere Jacques,
New Glarus Spotted Cow, Staghorn, Enigma
Lake Louie Warped Speed Scotch Ale
Central Waters Satin Solstice Stout
Furthermore – Makeweight, Proper
New Belgium – Fat Tire, Trippel, Red Hoptober, Shift
Tyrenena Rocky’s Revenge
Ale Asylum Hopalicious, Bedlam and Contorter Porter
Leinenkugel’s Honey Weiss
Red Bridge Gluten Free Beer.
Coors lite, Miller Lite.
Beer selections change often.
Wine
8 Wines by the glass or bottle.
A Tomato Pie is what pizza was, before the chain restaurants adulterated it into mass produced, processed fast food. What makes our pizza unique? Whole milk grande mozzarella (no part skim here), romano cheese, a little grande provolone, followed by high quality toppings with our signature fresh herb tomato sauce swirled on top of the pie. Our crust is on the thin side, made from cold fermented dough with no sugar, stabilizers, or dough conditioners. Some of the pizza chains use over 14 ingredients and chemicals in their dough…we use just 5 – Unbleached, unbrominated premium flour, water, salt, yeast and Olive oil. Each of our pizzas look different and distinct. We use no automated presses, everything is shaped by hand. Your pizza is then baked off in an old fashioned 650 degree brick deck oven. No conveyer belt ovens are used here because they belong in factories, not restaurants. Because of the way we make pizza, some blistering and char is not only normal, it is encouraged! As a result of all this, it takes a bit longer. Good food takes time to create, it isn’t slapped together. Come on in, relax in our comfortable dining room, have a glass of wine or beer and enjoy! We’re happy to serve you.
Tried your tomato pie and loved it. Fresh great ingredients! Worth the wait!
I am so looking forward to a couple different ones tonight. Thanks for making the best tomato pies ever!
Found your locally grown special hummus platter AMAZING! Loved the fresh quality of the pizza as well. Thanks so much Sal!
We went to your restaurant this past weekend. Incredible. In my top 3 favorite (the other 2 being V.P.N. places in Wi and Pa) pizzas of all time. Simply incredible. I am not sure if I can ever eat Little Caesar’s again! Pizza was out of this world, and your salad was superb. We also got the salami plate which was excellent. We couldn’t stop ordering things, everything sounded so good, and didn’t disappoint! Thank you! So excited to have a place of this caliber not too far from home. Would be nice to have a kid’s menu, as most of your pies are a little more on the “adult” side. Smaller cheese pizzas for them so we don’t have to compromise what we want ;o) Can’t wait to come back!
OMG … I’m origianally from Buffalo, NY and I have been searching (on a quest) for the best Buffalo pizza crust, sauce, and cheese replica that I haven’t been able to find in 34 years of living around the country. I first thought Nickle was the closest, then Papa Jimmy’s, but whooooooaaaaa, this place has hit the nail on the head! The crust is awesome, the tomato sauce and the cheese is perfect … I have found my home! Now I have to figure out a way to be closer to this place!