Weekend specials in Sun Prairie! 

We’ve got a weekend special that hints of warmer days ahead, a new soup, a friday fish special, and a new weekend family deal. 
Pie: local blue potatoes, roasted red peppers, alsum sweetcorn, crimini mushroom, lemon thyme crema, Sartori Cheese MontAmore, arugula tossed in a citrus vinaigrette, chives. Vegetarian for lent, but you can add meat if you wish! 

Family deal: 16” specialty pie, or build your own with 4 toppings, a market salad, and herb and cheese bread for $29. Carryout and delivery only. Friday and Saturday. 

Salmon Entree: seared crispy skin salmon, with crossroads community farm blue potatoes, roasted tomatoes, leeks, in a lemon butter sauce with fried capers. 

New Soup! My mother’s Pasta e Fagioli. A slightly spicy tomato and cannellini bean soup with pasta and Italian sausage. Italian american comfort food at its best! 
Have a great weekend!

Weekend specials in Sun Prairie! 12/1

Hey Sun Prairie, we have some specials for you this weekend!  

Entree: Veal Saltimbocca- Wisconsin veal pounded thin and pan fried with prosciutto, sage and served over fresh linguini with spinach with a buttery lemon pan sauce. A Roman classic. 
Pie: our take on an Italian hoagie. hot soppressata, giardiniera (cauliflower, carrots, pickled jalapeño, yellow onion), pleasant ridge reserve , banana peppers, finished with arugula tossed in a garlic vinaigrette.
And for carry out and delivery : get a specialty pie or build your own 4 topping 16 inch pie with a large salad, chocolate chip cookies and a 2 liter soda for $29. 
And finally, we’re open for lunch. 11-2pm. Come see us!

New winter menu in Sun Prairie! 

Hey folks! Brand new winter menu starting tonight! From a hearty braised short rib pasta, to “the prairie dog” we’ve got your dinner covered! All kinds of new items to try!  
Plus we have our Saturday and Sunday family special for carry out and delivery: get a large specialty pie or build your own with up to four toppings, large house salad, 4 chocolate chip cookies, and 2 liter of soda for only $29!
Check out our new menu online or order at salstomatopies.com 
Or visit us for the best happy hour in Sun Prairie. Buy one get one tap beers, rail drinks and wine, half off 10” bar pies. Open at 4!

Tuesday special at both locations-in honor of Danny DeVito’s birthday!

 So we won’t lie.  We adore Danny DeVito. Danny DeVito adores pizza.  So since it is his birthday, we’re giving you a present!   Buy any pie at regular price and you can get a large tomato pie with one topping for just $10!  Here’s the catch…well, there isn’t a catch. You just have to mention Mr. DeVito’s birthday when ordering!  Now order some takeout, and settle in with Throw Momma From the Train on Netflix. We think it’s the perfect way to chill ok this rainy night! 

Friday specials on Johnson St. 


What a beautiful night for dinner on our patio. Join us for: 

Special Entree: house porchetta served with sautéed beet greens, chioggia beets, baby carrots, tomatoes, blue potatoes. 

Pie: roasted squash, spring onion, asparagus, romesco sauce, squash blossoms and Underground Meats fiocco. Finished with micro greens. 
Tacos: achiote marinated roasted lamb belly, papalo, tomato Arbol salsa, spring onions, micro pepper cress.

Friday Specials! 6/27

chocostout rabe shiitake

We love creating specials at Sal’s from the areas best local ingredients! And tonight we have…

Antipasto: Underground Meats Coppa, Hidden Springs Ocooch Mountain aged sheeps milk cheese, over roasted local turnips, curried carrots, radish, charred spring onions and Vitruian Farms baby mizuna.

Salad: Vitruvian Farms mixed greens, Emerald Meadows snap peas, red onion, local tomatoes, strawberries, toasted pepitas, ricotta and cucumber vinaigrette.

Pie! Chili garlic and citrus marinated shrimp, emerald meadows farm broccoli rage, house made sassy cow garlic alfredo, sliced fresh garlic, calabrese chili peppers. A classic!

Dessert: House chocolate stout cake with chocolate ganache and fresh strawberries.

See you tonight!


Saturday specials!





Special app: underground meats lomo, shaved thin with Hidden Springs ocooch mountain aged Sheeps milk cheese, Indian farm shiitake and oyster mushrooms sautéed on butter, local greens tossed in a fresh lemon basil vin, curried baby carrots, radish and charred scallions.

Pizza: garlic tomato basil cream sauce, with marinated shrimp, spinach, Calabrian chilies, red onion and kalamata olives.


Entree: 3/4 lb Prince Edward Island mussels served with a curry coconut cream sauce, crostini and lime.

Dessert: poppy seed angel food cake served with Chantilly cream, pickled and fresh strawberries.

Happy Saturday, from Sal’s.

Friday Specials! 5/23

bucheron lamb rhubarb


Wow. What a beautiful day! We want to be outside, but instead we’re making beautiful specials for you tonight.
Antipasto – Emerald Meadows Farm Asparagus with melted goat milk bucheron, grape tomatoes, Hawkwind heat Mustard and house cured bacon from Uphoff Farm.
Salad: Grape Tomatoes, Cucumbers red onions, kalamata olives, chèvre, vitruvian farms mixed greens and a greek style vinaigrette.
‪Pizza‬: Local lamb braised in red wine, shiitake mushrooms, Emerald Meadows Asparagus, roasted peppers and onions, farmer john’s smoked gouda, shaved sartori extra aged asiago, finished with Vitruvian Farms watercress.
Dessert! House made tarts with local rhubarb, strawberries, and vanilla gelato made with sassy cow cream! (do I sound excited about the dessert? Yeah, I am. I want them all )
Have a great night!

Friday, April 11th, Phox Pie and other Specials.





What’s for dinner tonight? How about “The PHOX pie”. (Named in honor of one of our favorite bands) House made panang red curry, marinated shrimp, tri color bell peppers, red onions, finished with a daikon radish slaw and cilantro. It’s delicious, we promise.

Also serving Johnny’s house made founders porter chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and fresh strawberries.

And if you haven’t tried it yet, our Farmer John’s Smoked Gouda just became the 2014  Yelp Pizza Bracket Champion.  Out of 16 of the Madison area’s best pizza restaurants, our humble spot in Sun Prairie won the championship after 25 people tasted the pizzas and voted. We’re proud of that, for sure!


We’d love to see you tonight!

Saturday, 3/29 specials!




What’s for dinner you say? How about coming to Sal’s for:

Tonight’s entree: fenugreek and cinnamon roasted local pork tenderloin with calabrese chili and fennel roasted potatoes, wine poached apples and figs, broccoli rabe and goat cheese. Finished with a red wine reduction.

And our pizza: house cured uphoff farms kurabota pork belly, house garlic Alfredo, leeks, spinach, farmer johns smoked Gouda, roasted garlic and tomatoes.

Dessert: founders porter chocolate cupcakes with chocolate ganache.

See you soon!